Even works pur portedly about consciousness have very little to say about. The basic structure of intentionality, action, and meaning 35 intending in the ordinary english sense, in which, for example, i intend to go to the movies tonight. The notions of intention and intentionality have since been deployed in a multitude of ways in explaining speaker meaning grice 1957, 1989, speech acts searle. Searle one of the most amazing things about the past half century or so in analytic philosophy of mind is the scarcity of seri ous work on the nature of consciousness. Facts on the upper level, which he calls institutional facts, depend on human institutions and above all on an. In the construction of social reality, john searle argues for a twolevel ontology along the following lines. I shall at later points return to some of these issues. Holland hamline university in his previous books, speech acts and expression and meaning, john searle has presented and amplified a. A critical evaluation of searles connection principle 75 3.
Searle, the construction of social reality, new york. In contrast to tuomela and miller, searle claims that collective intentionality is a primitive phenomenon, which cannot be analyzed as the summation of individual intentional behavior. Searles central position is that linguistic reference is always dependent on or is a. Proper names and intentionality searles account of the problem in this essay, searle emphasizes the notion of intentional content, rather than the cluster of descriptions that kripke uses to characterize searles position. He is therefore using intentionality more in brentanos sense than husserls.
Searle has detailed theories about meaning and intentionality which are arguably far more interesting and if true, important than the chinese room. John searles speech acts 1969 and expression and meaning 1979 developed a highly original and influential approach to the study of language. I also learned quite a lot about intentionality, as you would expect. Intentionality is taken to be the crucial mental phenomenon, and its analysis involves wideranging discussions of perception, action, causation, meaning, and reference.
That was its proper function millikan, 1984, and, quite literally, its raison dtre. He exemplifies the fundamental distinction between iintentions and weintentions by comparing the hypothetical case of a set of picnickers and a dance troupe. More specific areas of overlap include the structure of intentionality, the relation of mind to language, searle s concept. Searle argues in proper names and intentionality that kripke failed to address the actual beliefs of descriptivists, accusing him of what can only be seen as straw man arguments. Pdf on feb 15, 2018, joel krueger and others published intentionality find. The intentional content is given in certain psychological mode, such as belief, desire, fear, hope, perceptual experience, etc. From speech acts to social reality barry smith it was in the oxford of austin, ryle and strawson that john searle was shaped as a philosopher. That is possible, and to some extent agrees with the following discussion. The present discussion revisits this article and notes some questions it provokes.
We are not trying to show that intentionality is really something else, but rather to explain it in terms of a family of notions each of which is explained independently, usually by way of examples. Intending is just one kind of intentionality among others. We are not trying to show that intentionality is really something else, but rather to explain it in terms of a family of notions each of which is explained independently, usually by. Searle on intentionality 471 especially not abstract entities. A critical evaluation of searles connection principle. More specific areas of overlap include the structure of intentionality, the relation of mind to language, searles concept. The article represents the core of searles account of social reality or, as he sometimes puts it, social facts, and the foundation of the account of institutional facts on which his famous 1995 book the construction of social reality focuses. As its title reveals, searle s book gives central attention to intentionality that apparently relational property. Consciousness and intentionality stanford encyclopedia of. The basic structure of intentionality, action, and meaning 35 intending in the ordinary english sense, in which, for. Before we demonstrate in what way institutional reality is constructed by combining the three discussed elements, we.
The problem for searle is that he has to somehow merge objectivity and subjectivity together, which seems conceptually impossible. John searle s speech acts and expression and meaning developed a highly original and influential approach to the study of language. Searle 1983 but rather with how intentionality is integral to subjectivity. Thus, for example, beliefs, fears, hopes, desires, and intentions are. Intentionality for the cambridge encyclopedia of the. Speaker intentions and intentionality griffith research. Introduction searles primary aim in his intentionality1 is to develop a theory ofintention ality 1983, vii. Collective intentionality is of central importance in social ontology. How does he manage to combine internalism with direct realism. Searle 1983 but rather with how intentionality is integral to. Intentionality is that feature of certain mental states and events that consists in their in a special sense of these words being directed at, being about, being of, or representing certain other entities and states of affairs. John searle the rediscovery of the mind pdf the rediscovery of the mind john r.
I will raise difficulties for searles attempt to maintain at the same time a tokenreflexive theory of perception and the thesis of direct realism. Social ontology is mistakenly, as i want to show, designed by searle as a. Searle on proper names and intentionality christopher hurtado. Most of all i thank my wife dagmar searle for her constant help and advice. Consciousness and intentionality are intrinsic and ineliminable, and. Facts on the lower level, which he calls brute facts, can exist independently of human beings and their institutions. Collective intentionality and the state theory of money erasmus. The basic stru,cture of intentionality, action, and meaning. Intentionality intentionality is a central concept in philosophy of mind and in husserls phenom enology. Searle agrees that meaning is a special form of intentionality.
Searles conception of intentionality with special reference to husserl wilhelm baumgartnerjorg klawitter wurzburg 1. John searles theory of consciousness the chinese room and. I will cast doubt on the persuasive power of this idea by dealing with searles notion of collective intentionality, which lies at. A comparison of some of the formal features of the intentionality of. First, intentionality has nothing in particular to do with intending, or intentions. John searle s speech acts 1969 and expression and meaning 1979 developed a highly original and influential approach to the study of language. The strength of searles book is his defense of an internalist view of rationality and action, which resurrects his views on intentionality and speech acts. In this paper, we will discuss its role in searles understanding of social ontology and institutional reality.
Now, let us return to searle s concept and take a shot at understanding his philosophy of mind. Searle contrasts mental states with language by claiming that whereas the intentionality of belief is intrinsic the intentionality of the utterance is derived. A successfully performed intentional action characteristically consists of an intention in action together with the bodily movement or state of the agent which is its. Searle 1980 the intentionality of intention and action. This reluctance was based on certain philosophical mistakes, primarily the mistake of supposing that the subjectivity of consciousness made it beyond the reach of an objective science. As usual, searles writing style was quite enjoyable. The primary aim of this book is to develop a theory of intentionality. In all these areas john searle has original and stimulating views. The aspectual feature cannot be exhaustively or completely characterized solely in terms of thirdperson, behavioral or. But this was my first major foray into thinking about intentionality apart from one or two other searle books in which he mentions it, so a. Searle denies that the chinese room has any of its own thoughts or intentional states other than jacks intentional states. Searle continues to say that the speaker imposes his intentionality on the words by imposing a condition of satisfaction. Metaethics in john searles concepts of reason in action.
Indeed, husserl calls intentionality the fundamental property of consciousness and the principle theme of phenomenology. Collective intentionality comes in a variety of modes, including shared intention, joint attention, shared belief, collective acceptance, and collective emotion. But behind both works lay the assumption that the philosophy of language is in the end a branch of the philosophy of the mind. Searle ignores this point and attributes intentionality to loosely defined mental states. This qualitative orientation can help illuminate the lived experience of. He thoroughly demonstrates in one chapter how a deductive model in rationality i.
Intentionality intentionality is a traditional term philosophers use for that capacity of the mind to be directed. Apr 21, 2010 searle argues in proper names and intentionality that kripke failed to address the actual beliefs of descriptivists, accusing him of what can only be seen as straw man arguments. Intentionality is seen by brentano as directedness of mental phenomena towards an object. But, although searles arguments about the baptism and the causal chain are both interesting and engaging, i will only address the first. Augustine and the greeks on intentionality, 23 richard sorabi aristotle on sensory processes and intentionality.
Intentionality is a philosophical concept defined as the power of minds to be about, to represent, or to stand for, things, properties and states of affairs. It is a special form in the sense that it is a form of what he calls as derived form of intentionality. Review of searle, the rediscovery of the mind journal of philosophy, 60, 4, 193205, apr. The theory has implications for conceptualizing intentionality and provides a framework for continued exploration of the nature of intentionality in healing for scholars as well as clinicians. Block, on the other hand, is prepared to grant that the homunculihead and chinabrain may have intentional states especially if we consider psychofunctional versions of those systems. On john searles 1983 conception, intentional states are states. But, although searle s arguments about the baptism and the causal chain are both interesting and engaging, i will only address the first.
Another important searles piece is intentionality 6, a book in which the philosopher talks about what there is at the beginning of every action in the world. As such, i will formulate a kripkean response to searles first argument and will show how searles particular argument fails to assimilate kripkes theory into searles descriptivist model. It was in oxford, not least through austins influence and example, that the seeds of the book speech acts, searles inaugural opus magnum, were planted. Holland hamline university in his previous books, speech acts and expression and meaning, john searle has presented and amplified a theory in the philosophy of language that. I hesitate to call it a general theory because a large number of. The rediscovery of the mind download pdfepub ebook. So the believers in original intentionality fodor, searle, dretske, burge, and kripke, inter alia would insist. Collective intentionality is the power of minds to be jointly directed at objects, matters of fact, states of affairs, goals, or values. For example, does the table or hussearle, as beyer 1997 puts it.
A contentiously classical approach, contemporary philosophy series, minds and. Prolegomenon to an adequate theory of intentionality natural or otherwise, part i. John searles book intentionality searle 1983 all future page. The twobitser was originally designed to be a detector of u. Searle abstract until very recently, most neurobiologists did not regard consciousness as a suitable topic for scientific investigation. Collective intentionality stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. The representationalist approach to intentionality searles speechact model of intentionality is an example of what he appropriately. Ancient theories victor caston connecting traditions. This is ironic, since searles argument against kripke is a straw man argument. The representationalist approach to intentionality searle s speechact model of intentionality is an example of what he appropriately. Intrinsic intentional states, whether conscious or unconscious, always have aspectual shapes.
Consciousness, unconsciousness and intentionality john r. The psychological mode determines whether and what kind of direction of fit the intentional state has. In searles philosophy the concept of intention is older than the practical reason one but, anyway, the two are strongly related. Second, intentionality intentionality withat must be sharply distinguished from intensionality intensionalitywithans searle 1983, ch. Collective intentionality, rationality, and institutions. As such, i will formulate a kripkean response to searle s first argument and will show how searle s particular argument fails to assimilate kripkes theory into searle s descriptivist model. The strength of searle s book is his defense of an internalist view of rationality and action, which resurrects his views on intentionality and speech acts. Cognitive science 4, 4770 1980 the intentionality of intention and action cognitive science is likely to make little progress in the study of humon behovior until we hove o clear account of what o humon action is. Its difficult to do them justice briefly, but if i understand correctly, he analyses meaning in terms of intentionality which in philosophy means aboutness, and intentionality is grounded in. Now, let us return to searles concept and take a shot at understanding his philosophy of mind. Intentionality and what we can learn about it from searles. Intentions, for instance the intention to buy a cat, are just one of many types of intentional mental states.
What has nonexperiential intentionality gets its aboutness by being such as would be seen to have it in the experience of an ideal interpreter. Jan 01, 1983 as usual, searle s writing style was quite enjoyable. Searle department of philosophy university of california berkeley, california. The aim of this paper is to present a sketch of a theory of action. Ronald mcintyre, searle on intentionality, inquiry, 27. The explanation of intentionality in terms of these notions is not intended to be reductive, since each is an intentional notion.
The idea fell out of discussion with the end of the medieval scholastic period, but in recent times was resurrected by franz brentano and later adopted by edmund husserl. Intentionality intentionality is a traditional term philosophers use for that capacity of the mind to be directed at objects or state of affairs in the world, that are. Theory of intentionality by ronald mcintyre and david woodruff smith 1. Intentionality of perception an inquiry concerning j. This is where the interface between philosophy of language and philosophy of mind becomes apparent. Intentionality mit massachusetts institute of technology. However, unlike searle, kriegel has consciousness confer intentionality both on otherwise meaningless symbols and on unconscious mental or cognitive life in much the same way.
353 1543 854 473 502 245 1520 697 1446 1075 1032 1151 76 34 261 1396 51 70 24 1220 976 664 1498 720 433 1349 616 1405 420 1521 408 179 1036 1045 1233 440 1466 570 1215 551 669 462